in

Prosecution of human trafficking in Moldova (TIP 2024)

international-2694682_1280
Foto di jorono da Pixabay

The government maintained law enforcement efforts. Articles 165 and 206 of the criminal code criminalized sex trafficking and labor trafficking. The law prescribed penalties of six to 12 years’ imprisonment for trafficking crimes involving an adult victim and 10 to 12 years’ imprisonment for those involving a child victim. These penalties were sufficiently stringent and, with respect to sex trafficking, commensurate with those for other grave crimes, such as rape. Article 168 of the criminal code also criminalized forced labor and imposed penalties of up to three years’ imprisonment. Law enforcement and judicial sector capacity remained strained by Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine and its effects on Moldova, including a refugee crisis. Authorities noted drug trafficking, cybercrime, and efforts to curb malign Russian influence had increased drastically in the last two years, forcing investigators to direct more resources toward these issues, reducing capacity for other issues, including human trafficking. In 2023, authorities investigated 49 trafficking cases (20 sex trafficking, 26 labor trafficking, and three unspecified form of trafficking), a significant decrease from 73 in 2023 but similar to previous years (57 in 2021). In one investigation, authorities conducted the largest law enforcement operation in Moldovan history involving 53 identified Bangladeshi and Indian foreign national labor trafficking victims. In 2023, the government reported prosecuting 64 alleged traffickers, a significant decrease from 109 traffickers in 2022 (37 in 2021). Courts convicted 33 traffickers (20 sex trafficking and 13 labor trafficking), a nearly fivefold increase from six in 2023 (44 in 2021). Sentences for convicted traffickers ranged from four years and eight months’ imprisonment to 16 years’ imprisonment. Moldovan authorities cooperated with their European counterparts on several trafficking-related investigations, judicial assistance requests, and extraditions. In 2023, the government cooperated with Tajik counterparts to share best practices and tools for financial investigations in trafficking-related crimes, asset seizures, and victim compensation.

Official complicity in trafficking crimes and corruption in law enforcement and the judiciary remained a significant concern. Despite improvements, such as removing legislative obstacles to confiscate unjustified assets acquired through illicit means, increasing transparency, and pre-vetting candidates for judicial and prosecutorial bodies, corruption remained a serious problem. The judicial system remained an impediment to bringing traffickers to justice with select members of law enforcement, the prosecution, and the judiciary complicit in trafficking crimes or implicated in corrupt practices. In 2023, authorities investigated and charged a district attorney/elected mayor for child labor trafficking. The government reported the investigation and prosecution of complicit government employees in six labor trafficking cases from previous years remained ongoing, including the investigation of a former member of the Center for Combating Trafficking in Persons (CCTIP) – the unit responsible for coordinating trafficking investigations throughout the country – for “suspicion of influence peddling” concerning a trafficking case under CCTIP’s management. While authorities investigated reports of corruption committed by officials, they did not always prosecute and punish them. Judges sometimes re-qualified cases from trafficking crimes to crimes with lesser penalties, such as “pimping,” or postponed hearings – a practice common among judges suspected of corruption. To increase transparency and efficiency in the assignment of judges to cases, all courts in the country utilized an electronic case management system. Yet, selective justice swayed by corruption continued to be a problem.

Perennial staff shortages among police and prosecutors and lengthy trials hindered anti-trafficking law enforcement efforts. In 2023, the government imposed a hiring moratorium through the end of 2024 on personnel in the public sector, exacerbating existing staffing shortages. The Ministry of Internal Affairs (MIA) – the lead ministry for law enforcement – already faced chronic understaffing and high turnover that was particularly acute in its subordinate units with investigative mandates, such as the CCTIP. Low salaries, complex trafficking cases, and pressure to provide quick results, made hiring and retaining staff within the CCTIP difficult. Furthermore, in 2023, the MIA reorganized the CCTIP, reducing CCTIP from 40 employees with 23 investigators and 11 prosecution officers to 21 employees with 18 investigators and zero prosecution officers. The reorganization essentially relegated the unit from the lead anti-trafficking investigative and police agency to a subdivision within the National Investigation Inspectorate required to coordinate with other subdivisions on trafficking cases, particularly prosecutorial actions, but helped facilitate information sharing and access to resources. While other subdivisions had human trafficking within their mandate, they also were understaffed and covered other crimes. In addition, the CCTIP did not have the technical ability to conduct surveillance or undercover operations and required assistance from the General Police Inspectorate (GPI) who often lacked the capacity to accept the CCTIP’s requests. As a result of these challenges, law enforcement did not always proactively investigate trafficking cases and often relied on referrals from NGOs. The National Investigation Inspectorate maintained a cyber unit that supported the CCTIP’s online investigations but lacked the necessary licenses to download and analyze content from electronic devices. The GPI maintained sexual assault response teams to serve rural regions of Moldova where police typically did not have proper resources to respond to reported trafficking cases. Similar to the MIA, the Office of the Prosecutor General (PGO) faced staffing challenges with multiple positions expected to remain vacant due to the moratorium. The PGO maintained a unit with specialized prosecutors, who coordinated anti-trafficking prosecution policies and supervised the work of regional territorial prosecutors when working on trafficking cases. The PGO also investigated child sex trafficking and online sexual exploitation cases involving information and communication technologies and provided guidelines for identifying, investigating, and prosecuting such cases. The Organized Crime Prosecution Office (PCCOCS), a subdivision of the PGO, had a specialized unit for prosecuting trafficking cases initiated by the CCTIP as well as cases involving criminal organizations. The PCCOCS also suffered from staffing shortages, limiting its ability to investigate complex cases, including transnational criminal organizations or complicit government employees. The coordinating council within the PGO consolidated the efforts of law enforcement agencies and set coordinated objectives and measures to prevent and combat trafficking. The Chisinau Prosecutor’s Office maintained an Anti-Trafficking Bureau and conducted the prosecution of trafficking cases from Chisinau municipality; at the district level, specialized prosecutors conducted the prosecution of trafficking cases. Within the judiciary, there were specialized judges trained specifically to handle trafficking cases. These judges maintained five-year mandates, which increased their experience and understanding of trafficking and created a judicial environment more sensitive to victims’ needs. However, the judicial system remained slow, understaffed, and amid a thorough reform, and lengthy trials continued to impede justice and often led to the acquittal of traffickers.

In 2023, the government, in partnership with other governments, NGOs, and international organizations, conducted a range of trafficking-related trainings for judges, prosecutors, and investigators, including on tools and techniques used for online and financial investigations and working with child victims. Participants noted trainings enhanced their understanding of a victim-centered approach in trafficking cases, the role they play in ensuring fast and effective justice, and the importance of interagency collaboration and assistance to victims. Overall, the government’s ability to fund key law enforcement and social protection institutes remained limited. As a result, the government relied on donor funding and international organizations to train police, border guards, labor inspectors, prosecutors, and judges.

from 2024 Trafficking in Persons Report – U.S. Department of State

2024 Trafficking in Persons Report – United States Department of State

flag-2526241_1280

Cote d’ Ivoire against trafficking (TIP 2023)

albania-2260977_960_720

Prevention of human trafficking in Albania (TIP 2024)