in

Transhumanism, eugenics, and Down syndrome

Photo by Gerd Altmann from Pixabay

Transhumanism refers to a current of thought that postulates that human beings can transcend their natural biological limits through scientific and technological advancements. This idea is rooted in a long reflection on the evolution of humanity. In 1957, biologist Julian Huxley, brother of writer Aldous Huxley, adopted the term “transhumanism” to describe the enhancement of the human species through scientific progress.

Before the emergence of transhumanism, the concept of human enhancement had already developed through eugenics: a doctrine that aims to improve the genetic characteristics of a human population through the selection of individuals or the modification of their genetic heritage.

Transhumanism raises a fundamental question: should science only be used to cure and support human beings, or can it also aim to transform and select certain characteristics of humanity?

The development of assisted reproductive technologies (ART) marked a significant step in this evolution. Initially conceived to help couples facing infertility, ART has also enabled new forms of embryo selection, particularly through preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD). This technique allows for the analysis of embryos before implantation and the selection of those to be transferred, raising the question of the criteria by which some lives are saved and others discarded.

As an extension of these practices, prenatal diagnosis has developed. However, it is important to distinguish between prenatal screening, which assesses the risk of abnormalities, and prenatal diagnosis, which aims to confirm or rule out the presence of an abnormality through more precise tests. Screening is not problematic in itself: it can inform parents, prepare for medical treatment, or adapt pregnancy monitoring. The difficulty arises when this screening becomes almost systematic for all pregnant women, regardless of age, and when its primary objective is to identify abnormalities to lead to termination of pregnancy rather than offering medical assistance. In several countries, the law requires doctors to offer screening for Down syndrome. Many families report feeling pressured by the way information is presented: “Do you really want to continue the pregnancy?” or “It’s not a child yet.” When Down syndrome is confirmed, the main option offered often remains voluntary termination of pregnancy.

Our focus, therefore, is less on the technique itself and more on its use and the boundary between medical prevention and the selection of individuals. From this perspective, some people with Down syndrome are sometimes described as “the first victims of transhumanism” or of the eugenic excesses linked to the advances in biomedicine. However, they could also be among the first beneficiaries of future advances in medicine and neuroscience, provided that these advances are oriented towards curing, supporting, and improving their quality of life, rather than a logic of selection.

It is therefore necessary to transform our culture of rejection into an authentic culture of life. In concrete terms, some families might be less inclined to choose abortion if they had access to more solid and personalized lifelong support solutions for people with disabilities, especially considering that their life expectancy, particularly that of people with Down syndrome, as well as that of many people with other disabilities, continues to increase.

This development represents significant progress, but it also raises new challenges. Many parents wonder about the future of their children when they are no longer around and about long-term support solutions. Society must therefore rethink its support systems to ensure authentic inclusion and allow every person to live with full dignity.

The best response to transhumanism is an authentic humanism, in which science remains at the service of the human person, and not the other way around. Because the value of a person does not derive from their performance, their physical, intellectual, or moral abilities: they possess an intrinsic dignity that must be recognized and protected in all circumstances.

Paolo Botti

© Tutti i diritti riservati. Riproduzione consentita solo chiedendo permesso a info@amicidilazzaro.it
(non verrà concesso a siti con pubblicità/ads o per usi commerciali)

© All rights reserved. Reproduction allowed only with permission from info@amicidilazzaro.it
(it will not be granted to sites with advertising/ads or for commercial uses)

The Illusion of the Europe Paradise: Risks and Truths Behind the ‘Boza’

travel-2065998_1280

The Fallacies of The Church of Almighty God (a Chinese religious movement)